Crime watch: ICC prosecutor is monitoring Ukraine invasion

Crime watch: ICC prosecutor is monitoring Ukraine invasion


THE HAGUE, Netherlands (AP) — The Intercontinental Felony Court’s prosecutor has put combatants and their commanders on recognize that he is monitoring Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and has jurisdiction to prosecute war crimes and crimes towards humanity.

But Prosecutor Karim Khan acknowledged that he cannot look into the problem that is staying most talked-about at this phase of the invasion — the criminal offense of aggression.

Western leaders have broadly condemned Russian President Vladimir Putin’s get to invade Ukraine. U.S. President Joe Biden on Thursday mentioned the invasion “was generally about bare aggression, about Putin’s need for empire by any suggests essential,” whilst British Key Minister Boris Johnson termed it “Vladimir Putin’s war of aggression.”

Though the international treaty that founded the Hague-primarily based court docket in 2002 has been updated to consist of the crime of aggression due to the fact 2018, Khan explained he does not have jurisdiction over that since neither Ukraine nor Russia is among the court’s 123 member states.

The only way the courtroom could get jurisdiction over the crime of aggression in the conflict in Ukraine is if the United Nations Security Council ended up to contact on the ICC to examine.

That “ain’t heading to materialize,” explained Brendan Plant, a Fellow of the Lauterpacht Centre for Global Legislation and Downing College at the University of Cambridge, for the reason that Russia is one of the council’s veto-wielding long term customers.

Putin has sought to justify his invasion by warning that pro-Russian rebels in jap Ukraine confronted what he termed genocide from Ukrainian forces.

Plant known as it a “concocted” authorized justification.

“Even if this twisted invocation of the proper of self-protection had been recognized, it is exceptionally tough to see how these types of a vast-scale invasion, with incursions throughout several internet sites throughout the country, perfectly past even the most expansive territorial promises of the separatist locations, could be justified as a important and proportionate act of self-defense,” he reported.

Although the criminal offense of aggression is out of the world court’s get to, crimes dedicated for the duration of the conflict are not.

Khan claimed his office environment “may work out its jurisdiction in excess of and investigate any act of genocide, criminal offense from humanity or war crime fully commited in just the territory of Ukraine.” That’s due to the fact Ukraine, though not a member condition, has accepted the court’s jurisdiction.

In a warning that could apply to Russia’s civilian and army leadership, Khan claimed that “any particular person who commits these kinds of crimes, like by buying, inciting or contributing in another fashion to the fee of these crimes could be liable to prosecution right before the Court docket.”

He extra: “It is very important that all get-togethers to the conflict regard their obligations underneath global humanitarian regulation.”

War crimes and crimes towards humanity address many offenses committed throughout armed conflicts including murder, torture, rape and compelled expulsions of civilians. Regulations governing the carry out of war purpose to rein in disproportionate use of power and protect civilians and troops no more time participating in combating this sort of as prisoners and the wounded. They also prohibit assaults on civilian targets and infrastructure these types of as hospitals and on cultural and religious web sites like church buildings.

Legal rights team Amnesty Global stated Friday that Russia’s invasion was “marked by indiscriminate attacks on civilian places and strikes on protected objects this sort of as hospitals.”

The group created the claim immediately after examining photographs, online video and satellite imagery of a few assaults carried out in the early several hours of Feb. 24.

“The Russian authorities, which falsely claims to use only precision-guided weapons, must choose duty for these functions,” stated Agnes Callamard, Amnesty International’s Secretary Basic.

The ICC was proven in 2002 to prosecute person perpetrators and their commanders accountable for war crimes, crimes towards humanity and genocide, in instances where by nations are not able or unwilling to keep their own trials. The criminal offense of aggression was added afterwards to the record of offenses in the Rome Statute treaty that established the court docket.

Whilst the ICC can’t prosecute any one for aggression in the Ukraine invasion, there is one more avenue, explained Carsten Stahn, a professor of global felony law and international justice at Leiden College.

“We have all over 40 states in the earth which have truly legislation on the criminal offense of aggression, and some of them could use this legislation also in buy to in get to training jurisdiction over aggression,” Stahn stated.

Universal jurisdiction is invoked by some nations in cases of war crimes and crimes versus humanity, allowing them to prosecute crimes fully commited exterior their individual borders.

Just one of the highest profile illustrations of its use was versus former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet, who was arrested in London in 1998 on a Spanish warrant. He ultimately was not put on trial thanks to ill wellbeing, but his case served as a warning for leaders accused of crimes that they may possibly no longer be ready to vacation the earth with impunity.

Whilst Ukraine is not a member of the ICC, it has recognized the court’s jurisdiction in excess of alleged crimes on its territory relationship back again to 2013. That acceptance types the authorized underpinning for Khan’s warning to combatants that he could prosecute crimes dedicated all through the Russian invasion.

The courtroom already has executed a preliminary probe into crimes joined to the violent suppression of pro-European protests in Kyiv in 2013-2014 and allegations of crimes in Crimea, which Russia annexed in 2014, and eastern Ukraine.

In December 2020, the then-ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda reported the probe uncovered indications that “a wide range of carry out constituting war crimes and crimes versus humanity within just the jurisdiction of the Courtroom have been committed” in Ukraine. Even so, the court’s prosecutors have not nevertheless sought permission from judges to open up a comprehensive-scale investigation.


Follow AP’s coverage of the tensions among Russia and Ukraine at

Ferne Dekker

Learn More →